Who Is Sherre Gilbert
I see Sherre Gilbert as a woman whose life has been carved by two enormous forces: a family tragedy that pulled her into public view and a personal resilience that keeps her speaking when silence would be easier. She is an American public advocate, best known as a daughter of Mari Gilbert and a sister of Shannan Gilbert. Shannan disappeared in May 2010 in Oak Beach, Long Island, a case that led police to remains tied to the Gilgo Beach serial killings. Sherre is one of four daughters. News outlets consistently describe her as the second eldest, younger than Shannan and older than Sarra Elizabeth Gilbert and Stevie Smith.
A full date of birth is not confirmed in court records, obituaries, or major news reporting. Entertainment profiles and secondary biography sites commonly say she was born in 1987 in Lancaster, Pennsylvania. IMDb lists 6 October 1987, but that entry is user submitted and not independently verified. A public social media account long associated with the family’s advocacy uses a handle consistent with a 1987 birth year, but that is a clue, not confirmation. Press and social media sometimes spell her name as Sheree or Sherrie. The form used in the New York appellate opinion, Mari Gilbert’s obituary, and CNN is Sherre.
She grew up in a poor family. Journalist Robert Kolker, who interviewed the family for the 2011 New York magazine reporting that became the 2013 book Lost Girls, has written that Shannan spent time in foster care while Sherre and Sarra remained closer to home, and that Sherre and Sarra were molested by a boyfriend of their mother’s. A New York Times review of Lost Girls summarized Kolker’s account that Shannan felt locked out of the family while sisters remained at home. Kolker later wrote that by the end of Mari’s life she had mended fences with Sherre, the daughter with whom she had the most fraught relationship.
Sherre’s confirmed public role began at least by 2011. She appeared with her mother and sisters at news conferences, funerals, and on television, arguing that Shannan’s death was a homicide rather than an accident. After Mari was killed on 23 July 2016, Sherre became the family’s most visible surviving advocate and an administrator of both Shannan’s and Mari’s estates. Current city of residence, occupation outside advocacy and media appearances, education, and finances are not found in public sources.
The Gilbert Family Circle
I want to lay out the family carefully because each person’s story intersects with Sherre’s in a distinct way. The table below gathers the key relationships and confirmed facts.
| Family member | Relationship to Sherre | Key facts |
|---|---|---|
| Mari Gilbert | Mother | Born 22 June 1964 in Jersey City, New Jersey. Died 23 July 2016 in Ellenville, New York, at age 52. Worked as a department manager at Walmart. Engaged to Elroy J. Shulterbrandt at her death. Became a national advocate after Shannan vanished. |
| Shannan Maria Gilbert | Older sister | Disappeared 1 May 2010 from Oak Beach after a 911 call. Remains found 13 December 2011 in a marsh near Oak Beach. Age reported as 23 or 24. Cause and manner undetermined by Suffolk County medical examiner. Independent examination by Dr. Michael Baden found injuries consistent with homicidal strangulation. |
| Sarra Elizabeth Gilbert | Younger sister | Killed Mari on 23 July 2016 in Ulster County. Stabbed Mari 227 times with a 15 inch knife, struck her with a fire extinguisher, and sprayed foam into her mouth. Diagnosed with schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorder, bipolar type. Convicted of second degree murder after jury rejected insanity defense. Sentenced to 25 years to life. Conviction affirmed 4 November 2021. |
| Stevie Nickole Smith | Youngest sister | Full name given in court papers. Listed as surviving child in Mari’s obituary. Testified for prosecution at Sarra’s trial. Kolker reported she told jury the killing was the result of long term hate and not a mental breakdown. Some secondary articles call her a half sister, but that distinction is not made in obituary, appellate opinion, or CNN. |
| John W. Cox Sr. and Junerose C. Gran | Maternal grandparents | Named in Mari’s obituary as Mari’s parents. Further biography not found in public sources reviewed. |
| Lori Grove | Maternal aunt | Mari’s sister, named in obituary. Further biography not found. |
| Elroy J. Shulterbrandt | Mother’s fiancé | Named in obituary as Mari’s fiancé at time of death. Not identified as Sherre’s father. |
| Sherre’s father | Father | Not named in obituary or in news and court sources reviewed. A user edited WikiTree page identifies a Floyd Gilbert and makes other claims that conflict with published birth order. That page is not treated as confirmed. Secondary celebrity sites describing the father as a heroin addicted man with schizophrenia do not cite a primary record. Identity and medical history not confirmed in reliable public sources. |
Sherre’s own partner and children are not established by name in reputable news, court files, or the obituary. Mari’s obituary says she had four grandsons but does not assign them to particular daughters. Sarra is publicly known to have had a son. A 13 December 2024 first person post on the Facebook page Praying for Shannan Maria Gilbert says the writer’s children will grow up without knowing Shannan as an aunt. That is evidence the page’s author has children. Names, number, and a spouse are not confirmed. Low quality biography sites that name a husband Alex Diaz Jr. and children Alex Diaz III and Ariana appear to recycle or confuse names from Shannan’s case. Those marriage and children name claims are disputed and I do not adopt them here.
A Life Shaped by Loss
Shannan’s disappearance on 1 May 2010 became the hinge of the family’s public life. She disappeared in the early hours from Oak Beach after a 911 call in which she said someone was after her and that people were trying to kill her. She had been working as an escort and had gone to a client’s home. Searches for her led in December 2010 to the remains of Maureen Brainard Barnes, Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman, and Amber Lynn Costello near Gilgo Beach, and later to additional remains along Ocean Parkway. Shannan’s own remains were found on 13 December 2011 in a marsh near Oak Beach. The Suffolk County medical examiner left cause and manner undetermined. Police have said the death was most likely non criminal, a view they said was consistent with an FBI Behavioral Analysis Unit review. An independent examination by Dr. Michael Baden, released by the family in 2016, found injuries consistent with homicidal strangulation, including hyoid damage, while also saying there was not enough information for a definite cause. At a February 2016 news conference, Sherre said, It’s not about trying to interrupt her from resting in peace. It’s about finding the truth.
Then came 23 July 2016. The appellate opinion in People v. Gilbert found that at Sarra’s residence in Ulster County, Sarra stabbed Mari 227 times with a 15 inch knife, struck her with a fire extinguisher, and sprayed extinguisher foam into her mouth. Sherre told Officer Antonio John Bell at the scene that Sarra had called that morning and said she was hearing voices. Sarra told police she had heard voices calling Mari the devil and a bad God. She had diagnoses of schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorder, bipolar type, and multiple prior hospitalizations. In February 2016 she drowned a puppy in front of her son, and Mari then obtained custody of that child. Stevie testified that Sarra had attacked Mari and Sherre less than a year before the killing and that the relationship with Mari was strained over custody. A jury rejected an insanity defense and convicted Sarra of second degree murder. She was sentenced to 25 years to life. The conviction was affirmed on 4 November 2021. She has been imprisoned at Bedford Hills Correctional Facility for Women, and secondary reports put earliest parole eligibility in 2041. Kolker reported that Sarra’s son is named Hayden and that on the morning of the killing Sarra texted Sherre about voices. Sherre told her to call 911 or their mother. Sherre later summoned police after pounding on doors and windows, and she was too distraught to testify. The day after the killing, Sherre wrote on Facebook that Sarra was battling a mental illness for 2 and a half years and that My sister Stevie and I are incredibly devastated beyond words as our mother was the backbone of the family.
Sherre’s Advocacy and Public Role
I see Sherre’s advocacy as a lighthouse in a long storm. She has appeared in media as herself, and those appearances form a public record of a family refusing to be erased. Credits include A&E’s The Long Island Serial Killer and the TV movie Search for a Serial Killer in 2011, Investigation Discovery’s Disappeared in 2012, A&E’s The Killing Season in 2016, 48 Hours appearances spanning roughly 2011 to 2020, 20/20 in 2023 and 2024, TMZ Investigates Gilgo Beach Serial Murders in 2023, and Impact x Nightline in 2025. In a 48 Hours segment she said that if Shannan had not made the 911 call, the other women might not yet have been recovered. She is portrayed by Thomasin McKenzie in Lost Girls, the 2020 Netflix film directed by Liz Garbus from a script by Michael Werwie based on Kolker’s book. Oona Laurence plays Sarra and Amy Ryan plays Mari. Amy Ryan has said she met Sheree at the premiere and acknowledged that the role existed because of the family’s tragedy.
Legal role confirmed by Newsday on 11 November 2025 is that Sherre Gilbert is a plaintiff as administrator of the estates of Mari Gilbert and Shannan Gilbert in a lawsuit filed in November 2012 against Dr. Charles Hackett, an Oak Beach emergency physician. The suit alleges he encountered Shannan on the night she vanished, medicated her, and is responsible for harm that followed. Wrongful death and intentional tort claims were dismissed in 2013 as time barred. In October 2025, State Supreme Court Justice Frank Tinari denied Hackett’s request to dismiss the remaining claims, finding triable issues of fact. Hackett has denied under oath that he met or treated Shannan. Ray told Newsday the case was built on circumstantial evidence and that the office had put more than 30,000 hours into it. Legal summaries also name Frances Nictora as a co administratrix substituted as a plaintiff, but that name was not rechecked in the court file itself. Finances, inheritance amounts, lawsuit damages, and whether Sherre has been paid for television appearances are not found in public sources.
Recent Years and Social Media
In July 2023, the day after Rex Heuermann’s arrest, Sherre wrote on the Facebook page Praying for Shannan Maria Gilbert that the time, effort, and dedication she and her mother put into the case was not wasted. She wrote, I wished, hoped and prayed for this day. I’m glad I’m still alive to see it. A legal summary citing NBC News quotes an email from her saying Heuermann deserves to rot in prison for the rest of his life and that she never gave up hope. In May 2022, after police released the 911 recording and again said Shannan’s death was most likely non criminal, Sherre and Ray held a press conference. Reported remarks include that Shannan ran for her life and was in fear, and a question about why she would then run into the marsh, along with the point that she was coherent enough to stay on a phone call for over 20 minutes and to knock on doors. In June 2024, Sherre was reported to have publicly broken with attorney John Ray over a press conference about Heuermann’s daughter, via an X post quoted by LegalClarity from the Long Island Press. That specific post was not independently retrieved for this report and is marked as reported, not re verified from the original X post.
On 13 December 2024, a first person Facebook post on Praying for Shannan Maria Gilbert marked 14 years since Maureen Brainard Barnes, Megan Waterman, and Amber Costello were found during the search for Shannan, and one year later Shannan herself. The writer says the pain of missing Shannan never lessens and that the writer’s children will not know her as an aunt. On 11 November 2025, Newsday reported the Hackett lawsuit can proceed, with Sherre named as estate administrator and plaintiff. In April 2026, Heuermann pleaded guilty in Riverhead to murders of seven women and admitted an eighth killing. Kolker reported in the New York Times that on the day of the pleas Sherre posted support for the other victims and added, The unwavering pursuit for Justice for Shannan continues. By early October 2026, public reporting described Heuermann as sentenced to consecutive life terms. A specific Sherre comment on the sentencing itself was not found in public sources reviewed. On 16 July 2026, the YouTube channel Sinister with Josh Zeman posted what it described as a never before released 2015 archive interview with Sherre about Shannan, from The Killing Season vault. It is an old interview newly published, not a new 2026 sit down. As of late October 2026, police and the district attorney still treat Shannan’s death as separate from the Heuermann murders and see no basis to reopen it as a homicide. The family, through Ray and through Sherre’s public statements, still disputes that conclusion.
Timeline of Key Events
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 22 June 1964 | Mari Cox, later Mari Gilbert, is born in Jersey City, New Jersey. |
| 24 October 1986 | Date widely given for Shannan Gilbert’s birth in Lancaster, Pennsylvania. Not re verified from a birth certificate. |
| 1987 | Year commonly assigned to Sherre’s birth, including IMDb date of 6 October 1987 in Lancaster. Not confirmed by primary record. |
| 17 January 1989 | Date given in secondary profiles for Sarra Elizabeth Gilbert’s birth. She was 27 in July 2016, which fits 1989. Exact day not in appellate opinion. |
| 1 May 2010 | Shannan disappears from Oak Beach after a 911 call. |
| December 2010 | Searchers find first four sets of remains near Gilgo Beach. |
| 13 December 2011 | Shannan’s remains are found in a marsh near Oak Beach. |
| 2011 | Sherre appears in early television coverage, including 48 Hours and A&E programs. |
| November 2012 | Mari, through John Ray, sues Dr. Charles Peter Hackett in Suffolk County Supreme Court. |
| 2012 | Sherre is interviewed by Kolker and appears on Disappeared. |
| December 2013 | Some claims in the Hackett suit are dismissed as time barred. Other claims continue. |
| About 2014 | Kolker reports Sarra attacked Mari during a visit and was hospitalized. |
| 12 March 2015 | Funeral for Shannan. Sherre tells mourners she wished more could have been done. |
| 2015 | Josh Zeman interviews Sherre. The interview is not released until 2026. |
| February 2016 | Baden’s independent findings are presented. Sherre says the effort is about finding the truth. Sarra drowns a puppy in front of her son, and Mari gets custody. |
| 23 July 2016 | Sarra kills Mari in Ellenville. Sherre alerts police that Sarra had reported hearing voices. Mari is 52. |
| 24 July 2016 | Sherre’s Facebook post calls Mari the backbone of the family. |
| 28 July 2016 | Visitation and funeral for Mari at Loucks Funeral Home, Ellenville. |
| Spring 2017 | Sarra’s trial. Stevie testifies. Sherre does not take the stand. Jury rejects insanity defense. |
| August 2017 | Sarra is sentenced to 25 years to life. |
| October 2018 | Court orders enforcement of subpoenas for 911 material in the civil case. |
| 13 March 2020 | Netflix releases Lost Girls. Kolker’s Cut essay on Mari’s last years is published the same week. |
| 4 November 2021 | Appellate Division affirms Sarra’s murder conviction. |
| May 2022 | Suffolk police release the 911 call and say Shannan’s death was most likely not a murder. Sherre and Ray publicly disagree. |
| 13 July 2023 | Rex Heuermann is arrested. Sherre posts that she is glad to be alive to see the day. |
| June 2024 | Heuermann is charged with additional killings. Sherre is reported to have disavowed a John Ray press event about Heuermann’s daughter. |
| 13 December 2024 | Memorial Facebook post from the Shannan page, written in the first person by a sibling who refers to her own children. |
| October 2025 | Justice Tinari refuses to dismiss the Hackett lawsuit. Newsday report runs 11 November 2025 and names Sherre as estate administrator and plaintiff. |
| 8 April 2026 | Heuermann pleads guilty to seven murders and admits an eighth. Sherre posts that the pursuit of justice for Shannan continues. |
| 17 June 2026 | Sentencing date scheduled. By October 2026 reporting describes life sentences as imposed. |
| 16 July 2026 | 2015 Sherre interview released on YouTube. |
| 30 October 2026 | Shannan’s death remains officially unresolved and is still not charged to Heuermann. The Hackett civil case, as last reported in November 2025, was still alive. |
FAQ
Was Sherre Gilbert born in 1987?
A full date of birth is not confirmed in court records, obituaries, or major news reporting. Entertainment profiles and secondary biography sites commonly say she was born in 1987 in Lancaster, Pennsylvania. IMDb lists 6 October 1987 in Lancaster, but that entry is user submitted and was not independently verified. A public social media account long associated with the family’s advocacy uses a handle consistent with a 1987 birth year, but that is a clue, not confirmation.
Who killed Mari Gilbert?
Sarra Elizabeth Gilbert, Sherre’s younger sister, killed Mari on 23 July 2016. The Appellate Division, Third Department, in People v. Gilbert found that Sarra stabbed Mari 227 times with a 15 inch knife, struck her with a fire extinguisher, and sprayed extinguisher foam into her mouth. Sarra had diagnoses of schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorder, bipolar type. A jury rejected an insanity defense and convicted her of second degree murder. She was sentenced to 25 years to life. The conviction was affirmed on 4 November 2021.
What happened to Shannan Gilbert?
Shannan Maria Gilbert disappeared in the early hours of 1 May 2010 from Oak Beach after a 911 call in which she said someone was after her and that people were trying to kill her. She had been working as an escort and had gone to a client’s home. Searches for her led in December 2010 to the remains of Maureen Brainard Barnes, Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman, and Amber Lynn Costello near Gilgo Beach. Shannan’s own remains were found on 13 December 2011 in a marsh near Oak Beach. The Suffolk County medical examiner left cause and manner undetermined. Police have said the death was most likely non criminal. An independent examination by Dr. Michael Baden, released by the family in 2016, found injuries consistent with homicidal strangulation, including hyoid damage, while also saying there was not enough information for a definite cause.
Is Rex Heuermann charged in Shannan’s death?
No. Rex Heuermann later pleaded guilty to murders of other women whose remains were found in the wider investigation. As of 2026 he has not been charged in Shannan’s death. Suffolk District Attorney Ray Tierney has said there is absolutely no evidence Heuermann was involved in her case.
Does Sherre Gilbert have children?
Sherre’s own partner and children are not established by name in reputable news, court files, or the obituary. Mari’s obituary says she had four grandsons but does not assign them to particular daughters. Sarra is publicly known to have had a son. A 13 December 2024 first person post on the Facebook page Praying for Shannan Maria Gilbert says the writer’s children will grow up without knowing Shannan as an aunt. That is evidence the page’s author has children. Names, number, and a spouse are not confirmed. Low quality biography sites that name a husband Alex Diaz Jr. and children Alex Diaz III and Ariana appear to recycle or confuse names from Shannan’s case.
What is the Hackett lawsuit?
Sherre Gilbert is a plaintiff as administrator of the estates of Mari Gilbert and Shannan Gilbert in a lawsuit filed in November 2012 against Dr. Charles Hackett, an Oak Beach emergency physician. The suit alleges he encountered Shannan on the night she vanished, medicated her, and is responsible for harm that followed. Wrongful death and intentional tort claims were dismissed in 2013 as time barred. In October 2025, State Supreme Court Justice Frank Tinari denied Hackett’s request to dismiss the remaining claims, finding triable issues of fact. Hackett has denied under oath that he met or treated Shannan. Ray told Newsday the case was built on circumstantial evidence and that the office had put more than 30,000 hours into it. Legal summaries also name Frances Nictora as a co administratrix substituted as a plaintiff, but that name was not rechecked in the court file itself.